Crossing The Angelic Defendant
1 hr 36 min
Hosts Steve Hohman and Olivia Espinosa are joined by personal injury attorney Susie Injijian, as well as actor and writer Sara Taylor. Watch as Susie cross-examines Sara, portraying a sympathetic kindergarten teacher whose vehicle struck a Guatemalan-born pedestrian. Listen in as Susie challenges Sara, and we break down how to confront bias in the courtroom. What’s covered in this episode: Talking ‘money grab’ and other biases in voir direWho to call to the stand when the damages aren’t visibleHow to keep a crying witness from derailing your crossThe tech savvy way to make sure your word choice sticksWhat you need to know to blow your witness’ testimony out of the water Time Stamps 00:00 What’s Cross Lab? 4:38 The importance of being in a plaintiff friendly county—and how to figure that out 8:13 Broaching the “b-word” in voir dire 16:35 What to do when your client’s damages aren't visible 24:15 Mock Case Overview: Lopez vs Maddison 30:29 Susie’s Cross: Crossing an “angelic” defendant 49:02 How to handle (and stay in control of) when the water works start 1:19:52 The key touchstones that will help you flip your witness 1:27:18 Top takeaways if you had to cross a witness like this To get free resources for your next trial go to TrialHaus.com Key Insights: How to Cross-Examine a Sympathetic Defendant Without Alienating the Jury When the opposing party is likable — a kindergarten teacher, a young parent, a community volunteer — the instinct to soften your cross can cost your client the case. But attacking them head-on will cost you the jury. The answer is neither soft nor aggressive. It's factual. In this episode, award-winning trial attorney Susie Injijian demonstrates how a calm, fact-based, step-by-step approach disarms a sympathetic defendant more effectively than confrontation ever could. By respecting the witness's humanity while methodically walking through undeniable facts, she removes the jury's impulse to protect the defendant — because there's nothing to p...