Limbo Land: MMP, Caretakers and No Time for Nonsense
57 min
Hosted by Phil Goff and Chris Finlayson, Cross Party Lines returns to a country still in limbo — no government formed, 400,000 specials still being counted, and a world that hasn’t paused to wait. This week: the structural problems MMP needs to fix, the constitutional rules governing a caretaker government, the Opportunity Party’s impossible coalition dilemma, Radio New Zealand’s $12 million scandal, and a world stumbling toward conflict while New Zealand changes the locks. In this episode: * MMP, overhangs and the commission that’s needed — An overhang of eleven is not a rounding error — it is a structural failure. Phil and Chris work through the options: reduce electorate seats from 71 back to 60; introduce the Bundestag rule that compensates for overhang with additional list seats; or Phil’s preferred more elegant solution — allow overhang MPs to sit but reduce the overhanging party’s voting weight in Parliament to reflect their actual party vote proportion. Chris notes the history: the Representation Commission has been quietly adding electorates every five years since 1996, steadily eroding the proportionality that MMP was built on. Both agree a Justice Select Committee inquiry will be a waste of time — it will be dominated by the party that benefited most from the overhang. * Caretaker government and the Opportunity Party’s dilemma — Chris corrects himself from an earlier appearance on RNZ: the Constitution Act was amended in 2026 — the Nanaia Mahuta amendment — meaning defeated ministers can stay in their portfolios slightly longer than 28 days. Otherwise, caretaker government means boredom, no papers and no decisions. On the Opportunity Party’s coalition choices: both RNZ and Talbot Mills polling show the overwhelming majority of TOP voters wanted a progressive government. Phil draws the direct parallel to Peters in 1996, who went with National against the wishes of 80% of his supporters and paid the price with the coalition’s collapse. * Radio New Zealand,...