Why Amazon Can’t Compete With a Great Auto Parts Distributor with Josh D’Agostino, President and CEO of Mighty Auto Parts
14 min
Josh D’Agostino, President and CEO of Mighty Auto Parts, joins Karthik Chidambaram on the podcast to explore why Amazon still can’t crack the auto parts distribution business, and what that reveals about where distributors create lasting value in the supply chain. Mighty Auto Parts operates as a franchise system with roughly 98 domestic distributors across 45 states and nine international partners, distributing preventive maintenance parts, accessories, chemicals, and fluids under the Mighty brand. Josh breaks down how the business differentiates through inventory management and stocking services at the shop level — a vendor-managed model that frees technicians to focus on repair work rather than shelf management. The conversation covers how Mighty Auto Parts has navigated tariff volatility, why fill rate and order accuracy are the foundation of any competitive distribution business, and how catalog data accuracy is the detail that separates a great auto parts distributor from an online retailer. Josh also shares his thoughts on where AI-driven catalog search is headed, what the growth of electric vehicles means for aftermarket parts demand, and how Mighty Auto Parts is diversifying into heavy-duty trucking, car wash products, and performance chemicals to stay ahead of a shifting market.