Skip to content
Minimum Competence

Minimum Competence

All episodes.

948 episodes · showing the newest 200

A Judge Orders the White House to Produce Its Big Law Deals & What “Rich” Should Mean in a Tax on the Rich

6 min

This Day in Legal History: Goodridge v. Department of Public Health On November 18, 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled, 4 to 3, that the state could not deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The case was brought by seven couples, represented by Mary Bonauto of Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, who had been turned away when they applied for licenses. Chief Justice Margaret Marshall’s majority opinion held that limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples lacked a rational basis under the Massachusetts Constitution, writing that the state constitution “forbids the creation of second-class citizens,” part of today’s opening quote. The court gave the legislature 180 days to respond. Massachusetts considered alternatives, including civil unions, but the court made clear that anything short of marriage wouldn’t satisfy its ruling. On May 17, 2004, Massachusetts became the first state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The decision came under the state constitution, so it couldn’t be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. The significance of November 18, 2003 is that it began the legal path to Obergefell v. Hodges twelve years later, through state courts, legislatures, ballot measures, and federal appeals courts, including Judge Richard Posner’s opinion for the Seventh Circuit that we discussed last week. It’s also a lesson about definitions: much of the case turned on what the legal term “marriage” meant and whom it included. Definitions turn out to be at the heart of today’s column, too. A federal judge has ordered the White House to hand over records in the American Bar Association’s lawsuit over the administration’s campaign against law firms. U.S. District Judge Amir Ali ordered the government to produce the agreements it reached last year with nine major firms, including Kirkland & Ellis, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, and Simpson Thacher, in which the firms pledged free legal work for causes the administration sup...

Trump Asks SCOTUS to Curb Judges’ Power Over Agency Rules, Ecuadorean Fishermen Sue Over a Boat Strike & DOJ Warns Sen. Warren

8 min

This Day in Legal History: “I Am Not a Crook” On November 17, 1973, President Richard Nixon took questions from about 400 newspaper editors at a convention at Walt Disney World in Florida. Defending himself against the growing Watergate scandal, he said: “People have got to know whether or not their President is a crook. Well, I’m not a crook.” It became the most famous line of the scandal, mostly for how badly it aged. The context matters. It was less than a month after the Saturday Night Massacre, when Nixon fired Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, and Attorney General Elliot Richardson and his deputy resigned rather than carry out the order. Just three days before the speech, on November 14, a federal judge ruled that Cox’s firing had been illegal. A new special prosecutor, Leon Jaworski, was pressing for the White House tapes, and the House had begun impeachment inquiries. Within months, the Supreme Court would unanimously order Nixon to turn over the tapes in United States v. Nixon, rejecting his claim of absolute executive privilege, and in August 1974 he resigned. The significance of November 17, 1973 is what it shows about accountability. A president’s denials don’t settle anything. The courts, Congress’s investigative power, and an independent prosecutor do. That system of checks, the power of judges to give effective relief, Congress’s power to investigate the executive, and the independence of prosecutors, is at issue in every one of today’s stories. The administration has asked the Supreme Court to further limit the power of federal judges, this time over agency regulations. Last year, in Trump v. CASA, the Supreme Court held that federal courts generally can’t issue “universal” injunctions blocking a policy for everyone, only relief needed to protect the plaintiffs. But the Court left open a different tool: the Administrative Procedure Act, which tells courts to “set aside” unlawful agency action. Courts have long read that to mean a rule found unlawful...

Intel Faces a Securities Suit After a 29% Plunge, Jensen Huang Hires Paul Weiss & New York Wins Back Its Highway Funds

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Justice Pierce Butler Dies On November 16, 1939, Justice Pierce Butler died after seventeen years on the Supreme Court. A Minnesota railroad lawyer appointed by President Warren Harding in 1922, Butler is best remembered as one of the “Four Horsemen,” the bloc of conservative justices, with Willis Van Devanter, James McReynolds, and George Sutherland, who voted repeatedly to strike down New Deal laws as beyond the federal government’s power or as violating property and contract rights. Their resistance helped provoke President Roosevelt’s failed plan to expand the Court in 1937. But Butler’s record is more complicated than that label suggests. He was the lone dissenter in Buck v. Bell in 1927, the notorious case in which Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote for an 8 to 1 majority upholding Virginia’s forced sterilization of Carrie Buck, with the infamous line “three generations of imbeciles are enough.” Butler dissented without writing an opinion. He was the only Catholic on the Court, and many have attributed his vote to his faith. Whatever his reasons, history has vindicated him on that case, and not the majority. The significance of November 16, 1939 is that Butler’s death came as the New Deal Court was taking shape, and the expansive view of federal power the Four Horsemen resisted became the law. But federal power still has limits, including on how the national government can use money to pressure states, which is the question in our last story today. Intel shareholders have filed a proposed class action after the company’s stock suffered one of the worst single-day drops in its history. On October 30, the day after Intel forecast weaker-than-expected fourth-quarter revenue and profit, its shares fell about 28.6%, wiping out roughly $140 billion in market value. The suit, filed in federal court in San Jose and led by the City of Southfield Fire and Police Retirement System, names Intel, CEO Lip-Bu Tan, and CFO David Zinsner. It alleges...

Gibson Dunn Lands Weil’s 120-Lawyer Funds Team, the Senate Calls Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnick & SEC and CFTC Nominees Head to the Senate

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Browder v. Gayle On November 13, 1956, the Supreme Court affirmed a lower-court decision in Browder v. Gayle, holding that segregation on the buses of Montgomery, Alabama, was unconstitutional. The case was brought by four Black women, Aurelia Browder, Claudette Colvin, Mary Louise Smith, and Susie McDonald, each of whom had been mistreated or arrested for refusing to give up their seats. Their lawyer, Fred Gray, filed it in federal court in February 1956, in the middle of the Montgomery bus boycott that had begun after Rosa Parks’s arrest the previous December. A three-judge federal court ruled for the plaintiffs that June, 2 to 1, holding that Brown v. Board of Education’s rejection of “separate but equal” applied beyond schools. The Supreme Court affirmed without a full opinion, in a one-line summary order. It denied rehearing in December, and on December 20, 1956, after the order was delivered to city officials, the boycott ended. Black riders returned to Montgomery’s buses after 381 days. The significance of November 13, 1956 is that a single-sentence order from the Supreme Court helped end segregation on public transportation, and with it one of the defining campaigns of the civil rights movement. The boycott showed the power of collective action; the lawsuit turned that pressure into a binding legal rule. It’s also a reminder, relevant to how much law this year has been made on the Court’s emergency docket, that short, unexplained orders can carry enormous consequences. Two weeks ago we covered the collapse of Weil, Gotshal & Manges. Now its partners have approved a wind-down plan, and the biggest pieces of the firm are being picked up. Gibson Dunn is hiring Weil’s private funds practice, a team of about 120 lawyers, including 23 partners, across New York, Washington, and London. Among them is Jonathon Soler, one of Weil’s co-managing partners, along with the heads of its private funds practice in New York and London. Weil’s other c...

Remembering Judge Richard Posner & Alaska’s Ballot-Data Fight in the Last Uncalled Senate Race

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Justice Douglas Retires On November 12, 1975, Justice William O. Douglas retired from the Supreme Court after serving since 1939, longer than any justice in the Court’s history: thirty-six years and seven months. He had suffered a serious stroke at the end of 1974 and tried for months to continue working before finally stepping down. Douglas was a former Yale law professor and chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission when Franklin Roosevelt appointed him at 40. On the Court, he became one of its most liberal and most individualistic members, a fierce defender of free speech and civil liberties, and the author of Griswold v. Connecticut, which recognized a constitutional right to privacy. He was also famously prolific and impatient, writing quickly, dissenting often, and publishing books on everything from conservation to travel. He survived two impeachment efforts, including one led by then-Representative Gerald Ford, who as president would name his successor. The significance of November 12, 1975 is partly about a remarkable career, and partly about the hard question of when a judge should step down, a question that arises again and again with life tenure. It’s a fitting anniversary on a day when we remember another long-serving, prolific, opinionated, and deeply influential judge, one who also left the bench on his own terms, and who, like Douglas, didn’t fit neatly into anyone’s ideological box. Judge Richard Posner has died. He was 87. The University of Chicago Law School, where he taught for decades, confirmed that he died on Tuesday. Posner had largely withdrawn from public life after being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease in 2018, a few months after he retired from the bench. It’s hard to overstate his influence. Posner was born in New York in 1939, studied English at Yale, graduated first in his class at Harvard Law School, where he was president of the Law Review, and clerked for Justice William Brennan. He worked at t...

Weil’s Lawyers Scatter, Anthropic Faces a Suit Over Claude Max Marketing & the Paper Trail Behind Florida’s New Property Tax Cut

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Buckley v. Valeo Is Argued On November 10, 1975, the Supreme Court heard argument in Buckley v. Valeo, a challenge to the campaign finance reforms Congress had passed after Watergate. The 1974 amendments to the Federal Election Campaign Act limited how much individuals could contribute to candidates, capped how much candidates and independent groups could spend, created public financing for presidential campaigns, and established the Federal Election Commission. A broad coalition, from conservative Senator James Buckley to the American Civil Liberties Union, argued that the limits violated the First Amendment. In January 1976, the Court split the difference. It upheld limits on contributions to candidates, reasoning that large contributions create a risk of corruption or its appearance. But it struck down limits on independent spending and on candidates’ spending, reasoning, in today’s opening quote, that in modern society spending money is closely tied to the ability to communicate ideas. Limiting spending, the Court said, limits speech. The significance of November 10, 1975 is that Buckley’s distinction between contributions and expenditures still frames campaign finance law fifty years later. It led to Citizens United, the rise of super PACs, and, this June, the Supreme Court’s decision striking down limits on coordinated spending by parties and their candidates, which shaped the election we just held. It’s a reminder that how the law treats money as speech, or as a source of corruption, can reshape elections. Weil, Gotshal & Manges is coming apart quickly. Two weeks ago, the firm’s leadership recommended an orderly wind-down after a wave of partner departures. Now its lawyers are scattering to rival firms. Reports say Kirkland & Ellis is taking around 40 Weil lawyers, Latham & Watkins is hiring several, and firms including Cravath, Paul Weiss, Simpson Thacher, Sullivan & Cromwell, Davis Polk, and Sidley have absorbed others. Weil’s res...

A Defeated Texas Justice Heads for the Federal Bench, a Judge Halts Trump’s Arch & Legal Jobs Hit a Record High

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Wickard v. Filburn On November 9, 1942, the Supreme Court decided Wickard v. Filburn, one of the most consequential and most debated decisions about the reach of federal power. Roscoe Filburn, an Ohio farmer, grew more wheat than his federal quota under the Agricultural Adjustment Act allowed. He argued that the extra wheat never left his farm. He fed it to his own livestock and used it at home, so it had nothing to do with interstate commerce, and Congress couldn’t regulate it. The Court disagreed unanimously. Justice Robert Jackson wrote that even activity that’s local and not itself commerce can be regulated if it has a substantial effect on interstate commerce, today’s opening quote. And the effect is measured in the aggregate. Filburn’s own extra wheat was trivial, but if every farmer did the same, they’d collectively buy less wheat on the market and undermine the program’s effort to stabilize prices. Taken together with other New Deal-era decisions, Wickard marked the end of the Court’s resistance to broad federal economic regulation. The significance of November 9, 1942 is that Wickard became the foundation of the modern Commerce Clause, supporting federal laws on everything from civil rights in public accommodations to drug regulation, and it’s still at the center of debates over the limits of federal power, as in the Affordable Care Act case in 2012. It’s a reminder that the most important questions about government power are often decided not in dramatic confrontations, but in cases about wheat, and today, about judicial appointments, monuments, and jobs. The President is moving to nominate James Sullivan, a Republican justice on the Texas Supreme Court who lost his reelection race last Tuesday, to a lifetime federal judgeship on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas in Austin. Sullivan lost to Democrat Chari Kelly. In fact, Democrats won all four Texas Supreme Court seats on the ballot, narrowing the Republic...

A Kentucky Law Professor’s Free-Speech Fight, Big Tech Sues Over California’s Youth Social Media Law & the Battle Over Trump’s Triumphal Arch

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Susan B. Anthony Votes On November 5, 1872, Susan B. Anthony walked into a polling place in Rochester, New York, and cast a ballot in the presidential election, along with fourteen other women from her ward. This was a deliberate legal test. Anthony and other suffragists argued that the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified four years earlier, made women citizens, and that voting was one of the privileges of citizenship that no state could deny. Two weeks later, a deputy federal marshal arrested her at her home for voting illegally. She refused to post bail. At her trial in June 1873, before Justice Ward Hunt of the Supreme Court, sitting as a trial judge, she wasn’t allowed to testify, and at the close of evidence the judge directed the all-male jury to return a guilty verdict, without letting them deliberate. When asked if she had anything to say before sentencing, Anthony delivered a famous speech condemning the proceedings. She was fined $100 and never paid it. Two years later, in Minor v. Happersett, the Supreme Court rejected the argument outright, holding that citizenship didn’t automatically include the right to vote. The significance of November 5, 1872 is that Anthony used the law itself, a vote, an arrest, and a trial, to expose the gap between constitutional promises and how they were applied. It took until 1920 and the Nineteenth Amendment to close it. Her case is a reminder that legal change often begins with someone willing to test the boundaries of what they’re allowed to say and do, and that’s exactly the question in our first story. A federal judge in Kentucky will hold a hearing later this month on whether the University of Kentucky violated the First Amendment by suspending a tenured law professor over his comments about Israel. The professor, Ramsi Woodcock, has made statements describing Israel as a “colonization project” and calling for the world to wage war against it. The university barred him from teaching and opened an...

Democrats Win Congress: What Divided Government Can and Can’t Do, Kraft Heinz Sells Maxwell House & the NYT Sues Brave

9 min

This Day in Legal History: The Tehran Embassy Seizure On November 4, 1979, Iranian students stormed the U.S. embassy in Tehran and took dozens of Americans hostage. Fifty-two of them would be held for 444 days. In response, President Jimmy Carter invoked the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, a statute Congress had passed just two years earlier, and froze billions of dollars in Iranian assets in the United States. The crisis ended in January 1981 with the Algiers Accords, in which the United States agreed to unfreeze Iranian assets, end pending lawsuits against Iran in American courts, and send those claims to a new international tribunal. A company called Dames & Moore, which had been trying to collect money it said Iran owed it, challenged that agreement. In Dames & Moore v. Regan, decided that July, the Supreme Court upheld the President’s actions. It found that the asset transfers were authorized by the emergency powers statute, and that while no statute expressly authorized suspending the lawsuits, Congress had long accepted presidential settlement of such claims, which the Court treated as implied approval. The significance of November 4, 1979 is the legal principle the crisis produced: presidential power is at its strongest when it rests on authority Congress has already given, even a Congress elected years earlier. That’s directly relevant to our lead story, because when control of Congress changes, the powers earlier Congresses delegated to the executive branch don’t disappear. Democrats have won control of both the House and the Senate, according to unofficial results from yesterday’s midterms. As of early this morning, the Associated Press had called 228 House seats for Democrats, well past the 218 needed for a majority, with dozens of races still uncalled. In the Senate, Democrats held 54 seats to Republicans’ 44, with the races in Alaska and Mississippi still too close to call. Recall that Alaska is where the Justice Department sued to block c...

SCOTUS Ends Trump’s Bid to Freeze California Ballots, a Judge Blocks Federal Noncitizen-Voter Lists & Why Refund-Heavy Tax Preparers Shouldn’t Be Red Flags

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Elk v. Wilkins On November 3, 1884, the Supreme Court decided Elk v. Wilkins. John Elk was a Native American man, born on tribal land, who had left his tribe, moved to Omaha, and lived among the city’s residents. In 1880, he tried to register to vote. The registrar, Charles Wilkins, refused, on the ground that Elk wasn’t a citizen. Elk sued, relying on the Fourteenth Amendment, which says that all persons born in the United States and “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” are citizens. The Court ruled against him, 7 to 2. It held that Native Americans born into tribal nations weren’t “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States in the sense the amendment required, and that leaving his tribe and living as a citizen didn’t make Elk one without some act of Congress naturalizing him. Justice John Marshall Harlan, whom we profiled last month, dissented, arguing that a man who had given up his tribal allegiance and lived under American law was exactly the kind of person the Fourteenth Amendment was meant to include. The significance of November 3, 1884 is that it took another forty years, until the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, for Congress to declare all Native Americans born in the United States to be citizens, and longer still before some states stopped finding ways to keep them from voting. On Election Day, it’s a reminder that the questions of who is a citizen and who gets to vote have been contested throughout American history, and that a registrar’s decision about one voter’s eligibility can end up in the Supreme Court. Today’s stories are the latest chapter in that history. The Supreme Court has refused the administration’s emergency request to make California set aside about 20,000 mail ballots from people the Justice Department says are likely noncitizens. The administration filed its application Monday morning, and the Court denied it the same day, without explanation and with no noted dissents, hours before the polls opened....

Weil Gotshal Plans to Dissolve, the US Sues Google Over a Returning Reservist & the White House Press Fight Moves to the Oval Office

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Black Tuesday On October 29, 1929, the New York Stock Exchange suffered the worst day of the crash that had begun the previous Thursday. About 16 million shares changed hands, a record that stood for decades, and the Dow fell about 12 percent. Investors who had bought stock on margin, with borrowed money, were wiped out as their loans were called. The crash didn’t cause the Great Depression by itself, but it became its symbol. The legal response defined American financial regulation for the rest of the century. The Securities Act of 1933 required companies selling securities to the public to register and disclose financial information. The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 created the Securities and Exchange Commission and regulated trading and margin lending. The Banking Act of 1933, known as Glass-Steagall, separated commercial banking from investment banking and created the FDIC to insure deposits. The central idea, borrowed from Louis Brandeis in today’s opening quote, was disclosure: rather than having the government judge which investments were sound, the law would require companies to tell the truth and let investors decide. The significance of October 29, 1929 is that much of modern corporate and financial law, and much of the work of the big law firms that grew up to practice it, traces back to the response to the crash. Earlier this month we marked the 1987 crash. Today’s anniversary goes back to the original. And our first story is about one of the firms that built its reputation in the aftermath of a later financial collapse. Weil, Gotshal & Manges, one of the best-known names in corporate law, has told its partners it plans to wind down. Weil’s restructuring practice made it the go-to firm for some of the largest bankruptcies in history, including Lehman Brothers and Enron. Now the firm itself is dissolving after failing to stop a wave of partner departures and, according to Law.com, failing to find a merger partner in recent we...

The Ninth Circuit Rebuffs DOJ on California Ballots, a Judge Says Maurene Comey Was Unlawfully Fired & James Comey Is Charged a Third Time

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Federalist No. 1 On October 27, 1787, New York’s Independent Journal published an essay signed “Publius,” titled “General Introduction.” It was the first of what became 85 essays, written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay, urging New Yorkers to ratify the Constitution, which had been signed in Philadelphia just six weeks earlier. Hamilton wrote this first one. Hamilton framed ratification as a test, set out in today’s opening quote, of whether people could establish good government “from reflection and choice,” rather than by “accident and force.” He also warned readers about something he saw as a recurring danger in republics: those who use zeal for liberty as a cover for ambition. “Of those men who have overturned the liberties of republics,” he wrote, “the greatest number have begun their career by paying an obsequious court to the people; commencing demagogues, and ending tyrants.” The significance of October 27, 1787 is that The Federalist became the most influential explanation of how the Constitution was meant to work, and courts, including the Supreme Court, cite it to this day to interpret the separation of powers, the role of the courts, and the limits on federal power. Its central idea, that a well-designed government channels ambition through institutions so no one person can bend them to their will, runs through all three stories today, each of which tests whether the government’s power to prosecute, to remove officials, and to run elections is being used within those limits. The Ninth Circuit has denied the Justice Department’s emergency request to stop California from counting mail ballots associated with more than 20,000 registered voters the government says are likely noncitizens. We covered this fight last Tuesday, when the President threatened California election officials with prison over these same ballots. After a weekend emergency argument, the appeals court ruled Monday that the Justice Department h...

DOJ Sues to Block Alaska’s Senate Results if Sullivan Loses, Meta’s $25B Penalty Faces Appeal & How SCOTUS Reshaped the Midterms

7 min

This Day in Legal History: The O.K. Corral On October 26, 1881, in Tombstone, in the Arizona Territory, City Marshal Virgil Earp, his brothers Wyatt and Morgan, and Doc Holliday confronted a group of cowboys, including Ike and Billy Clanton and Tom and Frank McLaury, near the O.K. Corral. The gunfight lasted about thirty seconds. Billy Clanton and both McLaurys were killed. Virgil, Morgan, and Holliday were wounded. The legend tends to end there, but the legal story is just as interesting. Days later, Ike Clanton filed murder charges against the Earps and Holliday. Wyatt and Doc were arrested and released on $10,000 bail. Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer then held a month-long preliminary hearing, with dueling witnesses: the county sheriff testified that the cowboys had tried to surrender, while other witnesses, including some considered neutral, testified that the cowboys had drawn first. On November 30, Spicer ruled there wasn’t enough evidence to send the case to trial. He found the lawmen acted within the law, though he criticized Virgil Earp’s judgment in deputizing his brothers and Holliday. The ruling didn’t end the feud. Within months, Virgil was ambushed and Morgan was killed. The significance of October 26, 1881 is that even the most mythologized act of frontier violence ended up before a judge, and what happened next turned on evidence, witnesses, and legal standards. The phrase in today’s opening quote, often attributed to Lincoln, captures the idea that in a democracy, disputes are settled by votes and by law rather than force. That idea is at the center of everything we cover today, as the courts take on an unusually large role in the run-up to the election. The Justice Department has sued Alaska election officials in federal court in Anchorage, asking a judge to block certification of the state’s U.S. Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan loses. The President said he ordered the suit: “I’m the one that said, ‘do it.’” The theory is unusual. Ano...

The NAACP’s Suit Over xAI’s Turbines Survives, a Judicial Council Presses a Dallas Judge in a Fitness Inquiry & What Illinois’ Swipe-Fee Fight Teaches About Tech Regulation

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Moritz v. Commissioner On October 22, 1970, the U.S. Tax Court denied a deduction claimed by Charles Moritz, a never-married man from Denver who worked as a book editor and paid a caregiver to look after his elderly mother so he could keep working. The tax code at the time allowed a deduction for those caregiving costs to women, widowers, divorced men, and men whose wives were incapacitated. A man who had never married didn’t qualify. Moritz, representing himself, argued that the rule was unfair. The Tax Court said the statute was clear and rejected his constitutional argument. The case came across the desk of Martin Ginsburg, a tax lawyer, who showed it to his wife, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, then a law professor at Rutgers. The Ginsburgs took the appeal together. In 1972, the Tenth Circuit ruled for Moritz, holding that denying the deduction based solely on sex violated equal protection. Their brief in Moritz became the template for Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s brief in Reed v. Reed, where the Supreme Court for the first time struck down a law for discriminating on the basis of sex. The significance of October 22, 1970 is that one of the most important lines of constitutional law in the twentieth century started with a small tax deduction and a self-represented taxpayer. As a tax professor, I’ll admit I love that. It’s a reminder that the tax code isn’t just about revenue; how it defines families, workers, and caregivers reflects and shapes who the law treats as equal. The administration has asked the Supreme Court to let it resume building border barriers across the Big Bend region of Texas. On October 2, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone halted construction across the roughly 500-mile Big Bend project area, along with the use of legal waivers for the project, while a lawsuit by environmental groups, including the Center for Biological Diversity, moves forward. Here’s the legal background. A 1996 law lets the Secretary of Homeland Security waive...

The NAACP’s Suit Over xAI’s Turbines Survives, a Judicial Council Presses a Dallas Judge in a Fitness Inquiry & What Illinois’ Swipe-Fee Fight Teaches About Tech Regulation

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Abrams v. United States On October 21, 1919, the Supreme Court heard argument in Abrams v. United States. Jacob Abrams and several other Russian immigrants had thrown leaflets from a Manhattan building criticizing American military intervention in Russia and calling for a general strike. They were convicted under the Sedition Act of 1918 and sentenced to as much as twenty years in prison. That November, the Court upheld their convictions, 7 to 2. The case is remembered for its dissent. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, joined by Justice Louis Brandeis, argued that the government may punish speech only when it presents a clear and imminent danger, not because it is unpopular or distasteful. He wrote that “the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market,” the line that gave us the phrase “the marketplace of ideas.” Earlier that same year, Holmes had written the Court’s opinion upholding a conviction in Schenck v. United States. In Abrams, he moved toward a much more protective view of speech. The significance of October 21, 1919 is that Holmes’s dissent became, over the following half century, the foundation of modern First Amendment law, culminating in Brandenburg v. Ohio in 1969. It’s also a reminder that the idea of a market, where outcomes come from competition rather than decree, has shaped how American law thinks about speech as much as commerce. And today’s column is about what happens when the law tries to dictate how a market’s plumbing must work. A federal judge in Mississippi has refused to let the Environmental Protection Agency end a lawsuit the NAACP brought against Elon Musk’s artificial-intelligence company, xAI. The NAACP and its Mississippi chapter allege that xAI and a subsidiary built and ran gas-fired turbines in Southaven, Mississippi, without the permits the Clean Air Act requires. Those turbines supply power to xAI’s Colossus 2 data center just across the state l...

Trump Threatens California Election Officials With Jail, Mahmoud Khalil Petitions the Supreme Court & HUD’s Fair Housing Overhaul Stays Blocked

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Saturday Night Massacre On the night of October 20, 1973, President Richard Nixon ordered Attorney General Elliot Richardson to fire Archibald Cox, the special prosecutor investigating Watergate. Cox had refused to accept a compromise that would have given him summaries of the White House tapes instead of the tapes themselves. Richardson had promised the Senate during his confirmation that Cox would be independent, and he resigned rather than fire him. Nixon then ordered Deputy Attorney General William Ruckelshaus to do it. Ruckelshaus also refused and resigned. Solicitor General Robert Bork, now acting attorney general, carried out the order. That night Cox issued the statement quoted at the top of today’s episode. The public reaction was immediate and enormous. Within days, Nixon agreed to turn over subpoenaed tapes, a new special prosecutor, Leon Jaworski, was appointed with stronger protections, and the House began impeachment inquiries. A federal court later found that Cox’s firing had violated the Justice Department’s own regulations. Less than a year later, Nixon resigned. The significance of October 20, 1973 is the principle that the Justice Department’s power to investigate and prosecute is not supposed to be wielded as the President’s personal instrument, and that the officials who hold that power have duties to the law that can require them to refuse. That principle is very much at issue in our first story today. The President has threatened California election officials with prison over how they handle mail ballots. Here’s the sequence. Days ago, the Justice Department gave California 48 hours to review a list of roughly 20,000 voters the administration says are probably noncitizens, or face legal action. Los Angeles County said it couldn’t comply because the administration hadn’t explained how the list was made. The Justice Department then sent a letter, signed by acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter, warning coun...

A Cyberattack Halts Bankruptcy Court Notices, a Judge Won’t Let the CFTC Undo Its Gemini Deal & Tesla Defeats Self-Driving Class Actions

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Black Monday On October 19, 1987, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell about 508 points, or 22.6 percent, in a single day. It is still the largest one-day percentage drop in the index’s history. Markets around the world fell with it. Trading systems were overwhelmed, order books backed up, and for hours many investors had no way to know what prices they were actually getting. The legal and regulatory response shaped the markets we have today. A presidential task force known as the Brady Commission found that the stock market and the futures market, regulated by two different agencies, the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, had acted as one market during the crash but were overseen as two. Computer-driven trading strategies in one had fed selling in the other. Among the reforms that followed were “circuit breakers,” coordinated trading halts that pause markets when prices fall too far too fast, along with closer coordination between the SEC and the CFTC. The significance of October 19, 1987 is the idea that market regulation has to match how markets actually work, and that fragmented oversight can fail when stress hits. The CFTC, which grew in importance after the crash, is in our second story today, which is about whether a regulator can simply change its mind about a case it already settled. A cybersecurity incident has halted the system that sends out notices for every federal bankruptcy court in the country. The federal judiciary disclosed the incident Thursday. It affects the Bankruptcy Noticing Center, which produces and mails or emails the official notices in bankruptcy cases, along with its website and the National Creditor Registration Service. The system is run for the judiciary by BAE Systems Inc., a U.S. subsidiary of the British defense contractor. BAE says the incident is isolated to that system and that it has taken immediate steps to address it. The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts is coordinating wit...

SCOTUS Again Backs Republicans on Political Ad Rates, a Judge Lets the Contractor DEI Order Stand & Eight States Sue OpenAI Over ChatGPT and Kids

7 min

This Day in Legal History: The Clayton Antitrust Act On October 15, 1914, President Woodrow Wilson signed the Clayton Antitrust Act. The Sherman Act of 1890 had banned contracts in restraint of trade and monopolization, but in broad language that left courts to decide case by case what was illegal. Clayton filled in specifics. It prohibited price discrimination that would substantially lessen competition, exclusive-dealing and tying arrangements with the same effect, interlocking boards of directors among competitors, and mergers whose effect “may be substantially to lessen competition.” That last provision, Section 7, is still the main federal merger law today. The Federal Trade Commission was created the same year to help enforce it. Clayton also took on a problem the Sherman Act had created for workers. Courts had used the Sherman Act against labor unions, treating strikes and boycotts as illegal combinations in restraint of trade. Clayton declared that “the labor of a human being is not a commodity or article of commerce,” the line in today’s opening quote, and tried to shield ordinary union activity from antitrust suits and injunctions. Courts read those protections narrowly for years, and it took later laws, like the Norris-LaGuardia Act of 1932, to make them work. The significance of October 15, 1914 is that it established a lasting principle of American regulation: that some sellers can’t charge different prices to different customers when it distorts competition. Our first story today is about a very different pricing rule, one that requires broadcasters to give political candidates their lowest ad rates, and about who else gets to claim that discount. The Supreme Court has sided with Republicans for the second time in a fight over discounted TV ad rates. Federal law requires broadcasters to sell political candidates airtime at the “lowest unit charge,” the same discounted rate a station gives its best commercial advertisers, in the weeks before an election...

Qualcomm Beats Arm but Wins $2, Anthropic Asks the Full D.C. Circuit to Rehear Its Pentagon Case & CVS Pays $315M Over Opioid Prescriptions

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Death of the Great Dissenter On October 14, 1911, Justice John Marshall Harlan died after nearly 34 years on the Supreme Court. Harlan was an unlikely civil rights hero. He was a Kentuckian from a slaveholding family who had opposed the Thirteenth Amendment before the war’s aftermath changed his views. On the Court, he became known as the “Great Dissenter” for standing alone, again and again, against the majority’s narrowing of the Reconstruction Amendments. His most famous dissent came in Plessy v. Ferguson in 1896, when the Court upheld Louisiana’s law segregating railroad cars under the doctrine of “separate but equal.” Harlan was the only justice to disagree. He wrote that the Constitution is “color-blind” and “neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens,” and he predicted the decision would prove as harmful as Dred Scott. Thirteen years earlier, in the Civil Rights Cases, he had also dissented alone when the Court struck down the federal ban on racial discrimination in public accommodations. The significance of October 14, 1911 is what happened to Harlan’s dissents after his death. Brown v. Board of Education rejected Plessy in 1954, and Congress revived the public-accommodations protections in the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Dissents don’t decide the case in front of the court, but they can shape the law that comes after. That’s worth keeping in mind for our second story, where a 2-1 appellate decision with a dissent is now headed toward review by the full court. A federal jury in Delaware found that chip-design company Arm breached its license agreement with Qualcomm and intentionally interfered with Qualcomm’s business relationship with Meta. Then it awarded Qualcomm nominal damages of $2. Both companies are claiming victory. Qualcomm says the jury found Arm failed to honor its commitments and acted to disrupt its business. Arm says the jury ruled for it on four separate claims and awarded only a dollar on each of the two...

Federal Agents Search Ilhan Omar’s Home, a Judge Is “Furious” Over Felled Trees at a D.C. Golf Course & Protecting Trump Accounts From Fraud

8 min

This Day in Legal History: In re Turner On October 13, 1867, Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase, sitting as a circuit judge in Baltimore, decided In re Turner. Maryland had abolished slavery in its 1864 constitution, but former enslavers quickly found a workaround: a state apprenticeship law that let courts bind Black children to white employers, often their former masters, without their parents’ consent. White children could not be bound under the same terms. Elizabeth Turner was one of those children, and with help from the Freedmen’s Bureau, her case came before Chase on a petition for habeas corpus. Chase ordered her released. He held that the arrangement was involuntary servitude prohibited by the Thirteenth Amendment, and that the law’s racial distinctions violated the Civil Rights Act of 1866, which guaranteed all citizens the equal benefit of the laws. In a now famous line, he declared that Black Americans were citizens of the United States on the same footing as white Americans. Within a year, the vast majority of Black child apprentices in Maryland had been released, although some state courts kept applying the voided law for several more years. The significance of October 13, 1867 is the idea that citizenship is not something the government can treat differently depending on who you are, and that federal courts will step in when a state uses ordinary-looking legal machinery to undo constitutional rights. Questions about citizenship, and about how the government treats people it views as political adversaries, are at the center of our first story today. Federal agents searched Rep. Ilhan Omar’s home in Washington early Monday. Homeland Security Investigations, the criminal investigations arm of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, executed a court-authorized search warrant obtained by the Justice Department, which said the search was part of an ongoing criminal investigation. According to sources cited in the reporting, the investigation concerns immigration pa...

DOJ Opens an Antitrust Probe of TV Networks Over Pool Coverage, Lisa Cook Faces a White House Hearing & a Judge Tosses an AI-Drafted Complaint

7 min

This Day in Legal History: The Alex Jones Verdict On October 12, 2022, a jury in Waterbury, Connecticut, ordered Alex Jones and his company to pay about $965 million to the families of victims of the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting and to an FBI agent who responded that day. For years, Jones had told his audience the massacre, in which 20 children and six educators were killed, was a hoax staged by “crisis actors.” His followers harassed and threatened grieving parents, some of whom had to move repeatedly to escape them. The judge later added hundreds of millions more in punitive damages and fees. Jones had already lost the case on liability. The court entered a default judgment against him because he repeatedly failed to turn over evidence, so the jury’s job was to decide damages. The verdict, together with an earlier Texas award, became one of the largest defamation judgments in American history, and Jones’s media company later went through bankruptcy. The significance of October 12, 2022 is a reminder of where the First Amendment’s protection ends. American law protects an enormous range of speech, including harsh, offensive, and mistaken speech about public matters. It does not protect knowingly false statements of fact that destroy private people’s reputations. That boundary, between what the government and the courts can’t touch and what they can, is at the center of our first story today, about whether the government can use antitrust law to second-guess how news organizations decided to cover the President. The Justice Department is investigating whether five TV networks, ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC, and Fox News, violated antitrust law when they briefly stopped providing shared “pool” coverage of the President. The New York Times first reported the investigation. Here’s the background. On September 19, the White House barred reporters from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico over their coverage, a ban we’ve followed closely. In response, the networks that rotate re...

New York Alleges TikTok Ran "Placebo" Safety Tests on Teens, Florida Goes It Alone Against Meta & a Judge Orders Christa Pike Execution Evidence Preserved

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Bostock Is Argued On October 8, 2019, the Supreme Court heard argument in Bostock v. Clayton County and two companion cases. Each involved an employee fired after the employer learned the employee was gay or transgender. The question was whether Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which bans employment discrimination “because of sex,” protects against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity. In June 2020, the Court answered yes, 6 to 3, in an opinion by Justice Neil Gorsuch. The reasoning was textualist. Gorsuch wrote that it’s impossible to fire someone for being gay or transgender without considering their sex: an employer who fires a man for being attracted to men, but wouldn’t fire a woman for the same thing, is treating the employee differently because of sex. The Congress that passed Title VII may not have anticipated that result, but the Court held that the words of the statute, not the expectations of its drafters, are the law. That’s the line in today’s opening quote. The significance of October 8, 2019 is the method as much as the result. Bostock shows how an old statute’s plain words can reach situations its authors never imagined. That idea runs through all of today’s stories: states are using decades-old consumer-protection laws against social media companies, and Christa Pike’s lawyers are invoking an Eighth Amendment ratified in 1791 against a modern execution protocol. Newly unsealed filings in New York’s lawsuit against TikTok contain some of the most striking allegations yet in the litigation over social media and young users. Attorney General Letitia James sued TikTok in October 2024 as part of a bipartisan group of 14 states, alleging the company misled the public about its platform’s safety. A judge has now unsealed portions of an amended complaint filed in August. The central allegation involves a feature called “Algo Refresh,” which lets a user reset their recommendations, for example to...

The EEOC Fights to Keep Its Law-Firm DEI Records Secret, Disney Takes On the FCC & What Sen. Kelly's AI Tax Bill Would Actually Tax

7 min

This Day in Legal History: The Stamp Act Congress On October 7, 1765, twenty-seven delegates from nine of the thirteen American colonies met in New York City for what became known as the Stamp Act Congress. Parliament had passed the Stamp Act that spring, requiring colonists to buy stamped paper for newspapers, legal documents, licenses, and even playing cards. It was the first direct tax Parliament had imposed on the colonies, and the colonies responded with their first organized, intercolonial political meeting. On October 19, the delegates adopted the Declaration of Rights and Grievances. Its argument was legal, not just political. The colonists claimed the rights of Englishmen, including the principle that they could be taxed only by their own representatives. Because they had no representatives in Parliament, they argued, only their colonial assemblies could tax them. The declaration also objected to the use of admiralty courts, which sat without juries, to enforce the act, insisting that trial by jury was a right of every British subject. The significance of October 7, 1765 is that it put the connection between a tax and its legitimacy at the center of American political thought. “No taxation without representation” is about who gets to impose a tax. My column today is about a related question that comes up every time a legislature designs a new tax: what exactly is being taxed, and does the thing being measured have anything to do with the reason for the tax? The administration is asking a federal court to let the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission keep secret the records of its investigation last year into diversity practices at major law firms. Some background. In March 2025, the EEOC’s then-acting chair, Andrea Lucas, sent letters to 20 of the country’s largest firms, including Skadden, WilmerHale, Perkins Coie, Debevoise, and Hogan Lovells, warning that their diversity and inclusion policies might violate Title VII. By April, the EEOC announced agree...

SCOTUS Opens Its Term With Boulder's Climate Case, the Harvard Funding Fight Hits the First Circuit & Poland Charges Google Over Publisher Payments

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Earl Warren Takes the Center Chair On October 5, 1953, which was the first Monday in October and the opening day of the Supreme Court’s term, Earl Warren was sworn in as the 14th Chief Justice of the United States. Chief Justice Fred Vinson had died of a heart attack less than a month earlier. To make sure the Court opened its term with a full bench, President Eisenhower gave Warren, then governor of California, a recess appointment. Eisenhower and Vice President Nixon attended the ceremony. The Senate confirmed Warren the following March, and he took the oath again. The timing mattered. Brown v. Board of Education had already been argued once and was set for reargument that term. Warren spent months building a unanimous Court, and in May 1954 he delivered the opinion holding that racially segregated public schools violate the Equal Protection Clause. Over the next sixteen years, the Warren Court reshaped American law: one person, one vote in the reapportionment cases; the right to counsel in Gideon v. Wainwright; the Miranda warnings; and major expansions of free speech and the rights of criminal defendants. The significance of October 5, 1953 is a reminder of how much depends on who sits on the Court when a term opens. A recess appointment made to fill a seat for opening day put in the center chair the justice who would lead one of the most consequential eras in the Court’s history. And today, exactly 73 years later, is again the first Monday in October, with the Court opening a new term and hearing its first case: our lead story. The Supreme Court opens its new term today by hearing arguments in one of the most important climate cases it has taken up: Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County. In 2018, the city and county of Boulder sued Suncor and ExxonMobil in Colorado state court under state law, alleging that the companies deceived the public about the role of their products in climate change and seeking compensation f...

Tennessee Calls Its Failed Execution a "Tragedy," a Judge Strikes Down the Federal Noncitizen-Voting Crime & New Mexico Seeks Up to $40B From Meta

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Thurgood Marshall Joins the Court On October 2, 1967, Chief Justice Earl Warren swore in Thurgood Marshall as an associate justice of the Supreme Court, the first Black justice in the Court’s history. President Lyndon Johnson had nominated him to replace Justice Tom Clark, and the Senate confirmed him that August by a vote of 69 to 11. Marshall arrived at the Court having already changed it from the other side of the bench. As chief counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, he argued 32 cases before the Supreme Court and won 29 of them, including Brown v. Board of Education. He had also served as a federal appeals judge and as Solicitor General. Few justices have come to the Court with a record of argument that shaped as much of the law they were about to apply. In nearly 24 years on the Court, Marshall was a consistent voice for equal protection and for the rights of criminal defendants. He was also among the Court’s most persistent opponents of capital punishment. In Furman v. Georgia in 1972 he concluded the death penalty was unconstitutional in all circumstances, and after the Court allowed executions to resume he dissented from death sentences for the rest of his tenure. That position is worth recalling today, because our first story is about what happens when the state’s attempt to carry out a death sentence fails. We have an update on the story we covered yesterday. Tennessee Governor Bill Lee has called the failed execution of Christa Pike “a tragedy,” saying no one wanted it to happen and that it was “deeply disturbing” that it happened in his state. As a reminder, Pike was convicted of the 1995 murder of a fellow Job Corps student, committed when Pike was 18. On Wednesday night, after the Supreme Court lifted a last-minute stay, officials administered two doses of pentobarbital. She lost consciousness but kept a steady heartbeat, and she was taken to a hospital for emergency treatment. Lee has suspended the remaini...

SCOTUS Takes Up Mandatory Immigration Detention, the Forced-Labor Tariffs Go to Trade Court & Tennessee's Failed Execution

7 min

This Day in Legal History: The Nuremberg Verdicts On October 1, 1946, the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg delivered its sentences on the surviving leaders of Nazi Germany. Of the 22 defendants, 19 were convicted and three were acquitted. Twelve were sentenced to death, three to life imprisonment, and four to prison terms of 10 to 20 years. Hermann Göring killed himself the night before his scheduled execution. Martin Bormann, tried in absentia, was never found to face his sentence. The other death sentences were carried out on October 16. The legal achievement of Nuremberg was the decision to hold a trial at all. The Allies could have simply executed the Nazi leadership; some officials argued for exactly that. Instead, at the urging of figures like U.S. Justice Robert Jackson, who left the Supreme Court to serve as chief prosecutor, they built a court, allowed defense counsel, admitted evidence, and let the outcome turn on proof. The acquittals mattered as much as the convictions: they showed the tribunal was deciding cases, not ratifying a foregone conclusion. Nuremberg also established principles that still anchor international law, most importantly that “following orders” is not a defense to crimes against humanity, and that individuals, not just states, can be held criminally responsible for aggression and atrocities. The significance of October 1, 1946 is the idea in today’s opening quote, from Jackson’s opening statement: that even when dealing with the worst crimes imaginable, the state submits to legal process rather than acting on raw power. That idea, that the government must work through courts and procedure, especially when it is detaining, removing, or putting people to death, runs through every story we cover today. The Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether the administration can detain millions of immigrants for the entire length of their deportation proceedings without a bond hearing. In July 2025, the Department of Homeland Securit...

SCOTUS Revives Third-Country Deportations, Jack Smith Faces the Senate & Why California's Wealth-Tax Critics Miss the Mark

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Integration of Ole Miss On September 30, 1962, James Meredith, a Black Air Force veteran, was escorted onto the campus of the University of Mississippi by federal marshals to enroll under a federal court order. The university had rejected him for no reason other than his race. The Fifth Circuit ordered him admitted, and Justice Hugo Black refused to let that order be delayed. Mississippi’s governor, Ross Barnett, personally blocked Meredith’s registration anyway. The federal appeals court held him in contempt. After nightfall on the 30th, a crowd of students, locals, and segregationists attacked the roughly 120 marshals guarding Meredith. That night President Kennedy went on national television to explain why the federal government would enforce the order, the address today’s opening quote comes from. The riot killed two people, including a French journalist, and injured hundreds. It took thousands of federal troops to end it. The next morning, Meredith registered. Listeners may remember we covered Little Rock earlier this month. Ole Miss is the same principle five years later: a federal court order is binding, even on a state determined to resist it, and the federal government will enforce it. The Constitution’s guarantees mean what courts say they mean, and a governor doesn’t get to veto them. That idea of judicial orders as binding law, not suggestions, has come up again and again on this show this month. The Supreme Court has let the administration resume deporting migrants to so-called third countries: nations that aren’t named in their removal orders and that many of them have no connection to. In a brief order, with the three liberal justices objecting, the Court paused a February ruling by a federal district judge. That ruling required immigration authorities to give people more due process before sending them to a third country, and a federal appeals court had largely upheld it earlier this month. The administration says it ha...

A Judge Blocks Trump From Using Counterterrorism Grants as Election Leverage, Alito Recuses From a Big Climate Case & Florida Asks a Court to Freeze OpenAI's Model Development

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Congress Creates the U.S. Army On September 29, 1789—the very last day of the First Congress’s inaugural session—the House and Senate passed the act that formally established the United States Army under the new Constitution. President Washington had pressed hard for it, reminding Congress that the militia provisions inherited from the Articles of Confederation were inadequate and that the nation needed a standing military establishment placed on a proper constitutional footing. The legal significance lies less in the creation of a fighting force than in how that force was subordinated. The Constitution had already divided military power deliberately: Congress alone can raise and fund armies and declare war, while the President serves as Commander-in-Chief. The 1789 Act operationalized that division, embedding the bedrock American principle of civilian control of the military—that the armed forces answer to elected civilian authority and operate within, not above, the rule of law. The Framers were deeply wary of standing armies and concentrated power; their answer was not to forbid a military, but to fracture control over it between the branches so no single actor could wield it unchecked. The significance of September 29, 1789 is that principle—power channeled through congressional authorization and constitutional limits rather than executive will alone. And that is precisely the thread running through our lead story today: a dispute over whether the executive branch can wield federal money as a lever to force its policy preferences on the states, or whether it may only do what Congress has actually authorized. The names change over 237 years; the fundamental question—who gets to exercise power, and with whose permission—does not. A federal judge has blocked the administration from tying federal counterterrorism grants to whether states adopt its preferred election-administration changes—the latest in a long string of election-related def...

A New Mexico Jury Finds Meta Misled Millions Over Cambridge Analytica, TikTok Pays Alabama to Dodge the First Teen-Harms Trial & SCOTUS Revives the SAVE Voter Checks

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Black Sox Indictment On September 28, 1920, a Chicago grand jury indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series in exchange for money from a gambling syndicate. That morning, pitcher Eddie Cicotte and “Shoeless” Joe Jackson had reportedly confessed. The scandal—forever after known as the “Black Sox”—remains one of the most famous intersections of crime, sport, and law in American history, and its legal legacy is more instructive than the folklore suggests. Here’s the twist that every law student should sit with. The eight players went to trial on criminal conspiracy charges, and in 1921, a jury acquitted all of them. But the very next day, baseball’s newly installed commissioner, federal judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, banned all eight from organized baseball for life—famously declaring that regardless of any jury verdict, no player who fixes games or consorts with gamblers would ever play professional baseball again. So you have a stark divergence: the criminal-justice system, applying its high beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard, found them not guilty, while a private governing body, applying its own rules and lower burden of proof, imposed the harshest sanction it could. The significance of September 28, 1920 is that lesson in parallel systems of accountability. Being cleared in a court of law is not the same as being cleared everywhere—private institutions, licensing bodies, and employers routinely impose their own consequences under their own standards, and they’re generally entitled to. It’s a theme that runs straight through today’s episode, where we’ll see companies held to account not by criminal courts but by state consumer-protection laws and civil juries—the many rooms, beyond the criminal courthouse, in which accountability actually happens. A jury in Santa Fe has found that Meta misled New Mexico residents about how it protected their data—and the potential penalties are genuin...

Reporters Turned Away From the White House Despite a Court Order, the ABA Fights for Its Accreditation Power & New York Calls Polymarket Illegal Gambling

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Congress Proposes the Bill of Rights On September 25, 1789, the First Congress agreed on twelve proposed amendments to the newly ratified Constitution and sent them to the states for ratification. Ten of those twelve would be ratified by the states in December 1791, and we know them today as the Bill of Rights. It was the fulfillment of a promise—many states had ratified the Constitution only on the understanding that a bill of rights protecting individual liberties would swiftly follow. The amendments are the beating heart of American individual liberty. The First Amendment’s protections for speech, press, religion, and assembly; the Fourth Amendment’s shield against unreasonable searches; the Fifth and Sixth Amendments’ guarantees of due process and fair trials; the Eighth’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. What’s remarkable is how the meaning of these spare, elegant clauses has been fought over and elaborated for more than two centuries—the words are fixed, but their application to new circumstances is a never-ending project. It’s worth remembering, too, that two of the original twelve weren’t ratified in 1789: one concerning congressional apportionment, and one on congressional pay—and that pay amendment was finally ratified in 1992, more than 200 years later, as the 27th Amendment. The significance of September 25, 1789 is that it created the framework of enumerated rights that Americans invoke against their government every single day—and never more directly than in today’s lead story, which is, at bottom, a First Amendment fight over freedom of the press playing out at the doors of the White House. On the anniversary of the day those freedoms were proposed, we watch a court try to enforce them in real time. We have a remarkable follow-up to a story we covered earlier this week: the White House barred reporters from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico from entering—just hours after a federal judge ordered their access restored and deemed t...

Missouri's Map Hits SCOTUS a Third Time, a Judge Tosses Michigan's Climate-Antitrust Suit Against Big Oil & OpenAI Turns Musk's SEC Filings Against Him

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Judiciary Act of 1789 On September 24, 1789, President George Washington signed the Judiciary Act of 1789 into law—one of the very first acts of the very first Congress, and a document that turned the skeletal promise of Article III into a functioning national court system. The Constitution had created “one supreme Court” and left everything else to Congress’s imagination. The Judiciary Act supplied the imagination: it built a three-tiered federal judiciary of district courts, circuit courts, and the Supreme Court; it fixed the number of justices at six; and it created the office of Attorney General. The Act’s most consequential provision turned out to be a quiet one: Section 25, which gave the Supreme Court the power to review and reverse state-court decisions that ran against federal law or the Constitution. That authority—federal judicial supremacy over state courts on questions of federal law—was the seed of much of what the Supreme Court would later become, and Section 13 of the same Act was the very provision the Court would strike down in Marbury v. Madison, establishing judicial review itself. In other words, the machinery of American judicial power, and the Court’s authority to police the boundary between state and federal law, traces directly to this statute. The significance of September 24, 1789 is that it is the architecture beneath essentially everything we cover—the district courts where cases begin, the circuit courts of appeals that review them, and the Supreme Court that sits atop it all. And it’s a strikingly apt anniversary, because our lead story is that very system in action, and under strain: a dispute ricocheting between a state supreme court, a federal district judge, a federal circuit court, and the U.S. Supreme Court—the exact interplay of state and federal judicial power that the Act of 1789 first set in motion. The fight over Missouri’s congressional map is back at the U.S. Supreme Court—for the third time...

Trump Asks SCOTUS to Detain a Pro-Palestinian Scholar, a Federal Judge Takes Leave After a "Super Drunk" Conviction & DoorDash's $131.5M NYC Pay Settlement

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Capture of John André On September 23, 1780, three American militiamen stopped a man riding toward British lines near Tarrytown, New York. Hidden in his boot were documents and maps of the fortifications at West Point. The man was Major John André, adjutant general of the British Army—and the papers exposed one of the most infamous plots in American history: General Benedict Arnold’s secret agreement to surrender West Point to the British in exchange for money and a British command. Arnold escaped to the enemy; his name became a synonym for traitor. André was not so lucky. The legal aftermath is what makes this a landmark. André was tried not in a civilian court but before a board of fourteen American general officers—a military tribunal—which found him to be a spy and condemned him to death. He was hanged on October 2, 1780. And here’s the part worth pausing on: André conducted himself with such dignity, and the proceedings raised such difficult questions, that his case became an enduring reference point in the law of war and the treatment of spies. Even George Washington, who approved the execution, wrestled with it. The core issues—what process is owed to someone the government has seized on national-security grounds, when a military tribunal may substitute for an ordinary court, and how a nation balances self-preservation against the procedural fairness it claims to stand for—are not relics. They run from André, through the Civil War case of Ex parte Milligan, through the World War II saboteur case of Ex parte Quirin, all the way to the post-9/11 Guantanamo litigation. The significance of September 23, 1780 is that it poses, at the very founding of the country, the permanent question of how a nation treats those it deems dangerous to its security—and how much process it owes them even so. That question is not historical trivia today. It is, almost exactly, the question in our lead story. The Trump administration has asked the Supre...

Paramount Settles With the States to Clear Its Warner Bros. Merger, the Botched-Bar-Exam Vendor Pays Up & Why Tariffs Need an Unwinding Mechanism

9 min

This Day in Legal History: The Preliminary Emancipation Proclamation On September 22, 1862, following the Union’s costly victory at Antietam, President Abraham Lincoln issued the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation. It gave the Confederate states an ultimatum: return to the Union by January 1, 1863, or the enslaved people in the rebelling states “shall be then, thenceforward, and forever free.” The Confederacy did not yield, and on New Year’s Day 1863, Lincoln issued the final Proclamation, recasting the Civil War as a war against slavery and setting more than three million people on the path to freedom. For legal history, the Proclamation is a landmark study in the scope—and the limits—of executive power. Lincoln did not act under a statute passed by Congress; he acted as Commander-in-Chief, framing emancipation as a “fit and necessary war measure” to weaken the Confederacy. That’s why the Proclamation, by its own terms, reached only the areas in rebellion—not the border states loyal to the Union, where Lincoln doubted his war powers extended. It was a document acutely aware of its own legal boundaries. Lincoln understood that a wartime executive order might not survive the war’s end, which is precisely why he pushed so hard for the 13th Amendment—to place the abolition of slavery on the permanent, unshakable footing of the Constitution rather than the contested ground of a presidential proclamation. The significance of September 22, 1862 is that it is one of the most consequential exercises of executive authority in American history—and a permanent lesson in that authority’s nature. It showed both the enormous power a president can wield in a crisis and the reason such power is inherently limited and temporary, requiring the other branches to make it durable. That tension—between decisive executive action and the checks that legitimate and constrain it—runs directly into my column today, which is, at its heart, about exactly that balance. Paramount has settled w...

Tesla's Race-Discrimination Trial Opens, CNN, MS NOW and Politico Sue Over a White House Press Ban & Law Schools Confront AI

8 min

This Day in Legal History: Sandra Day O’Connor Confirmed On September 21, 1981, the United States Senate voted 99 to 0 to confirm Sandra Day O’Connor to the Supreme Court of the United States, making her the first woman ever to sit on the nation’s highest court—191 years after the Court was established. Nominated by President Ronald Reagan, who had pledged during his campaign to name a woman to the Court, O’Connor sailed through confirmation with unanimous support, the lone missing vote belonging to a senator away at a conference. O’Connor’s path to that seat is a story about the barriers she broke to get there. A graduate near the top of her class at Stanford Law School, she nonetheless found that law firms in the early 1950s would not hire a woman as an attorney—one offered her a job as a legal secretary. She built her career in public service and Arizona state government and judiciary instead, and that pragmatic, real-world background shaped the justice she became: not an ideologue, but a cautious, case-by-case decider who for years held the pivotal swing vote on a closely divided Court, casting the deciding ballot on questions from affirmative action to abortion to the limits of executive power. The significance of September 21, 1981 is both symbolic and substantive. Symbolically, it shattered a two-century barrier and reshaped who Americans could imagine wielding the judicial power. Substantively, O’Connor’s controlling opinions defined American law for a generation. And it’s a fitting anniversary for today, because our lead story is about a workplace accused of denying opportunity on the basis of who people are—a reminder that the promise of equal treatment that O’Connor’s own career embodied remains, so often, a promise the law is still fighting to keep. Tesla is heading to trial in California over allegations that it allowed rampant race discrimination against Black workers at its flagship Fremont assembly plant—one of the most significant employment-discrim...

Charlie Kirk's Family Eyes a Suit Against UVU, Noncitizen-Voting Defendants Challenge the Law Itself & the CLARITY Act Crashes in the Senate

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The First Peacetime Draft On September 16, 1940, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Selective Training and Service Act, establishing the first peacetime military draft in American history. With France fallen and Britain under siege, the country was bracing for a war it had not yet entered, and the Act required men in a broad age range to register for potential conscription. Within a month, the first registration was underway; within two, the first draftees were entering service. The law sits at the heart of one of constitutional law’s most fundamental questions: the scope of federal power over the individual. Congress’s authority to raise armies is explicit in the Constitution, and the Supreme Court had already upheld conscription during World War I in the Selective Draft Law Cases of 1918, rejecting arguments that a compelled draft amounted to involuntary servitude barred by the 13th Amendment. But doing it in peacetime was new, and it sharpened the debate over how far the national government could reach into a citizen’s life absent a declared war. The significance of September 16, 1940 echoes for decades. The draft it created would swell to power the American war effort, and the Selective Service system it established would endure through Korea and Vietnam—where it became the flashpoint for some of the most important First Amendment cases in our history, like United States v. O’Brien, the draft-card burning case that gave us the modern test for regulating symbolic speech. It’s a fitting anniversary for today, because our second story is, at its core, about that same enduring question—the limits of federal power to reach and prosecute individuals—just in the context of elections and immigration rather than war. The family of Charlie Kirk plans to sue Utah Valley University over alleged security failures at the campus event where the conservative activist was shot and killed last September. According to the reporting, the family’s...

Supreme Court Blocks Trump's Mail-Ballot Restrictions, Musk's X Drops Apple but Keeps Suing OpenAI & Why Breaking Up the Big Four Won't Fix Auditor Misconduct

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The 16th Street Baptist Church Bombing On September 15, 1963, members of the Ku Klux Klan planted dynamite beneath the steps of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama—a hub of the civil rights movement—and detonated it on a Sunday morning. The blast killed four young Black girls: Addie Mae Collins, Cynthia Wesley, Carole Robertson, and Denise McNair. It was an act of racial terrorism aimed at the heart of a community, and it became one of the galvanizing atrocities of the civil rights era. The legal aftermath is a study in the agonizing slowness of justice. Though the FBI identified suspects within a few years, no one was prosecuted at the time—an all-too-familiar failure of Southern justice to hold white supremacists accountable for violence against Black Americans. It took fourteen years for the first conviction: Robert Chambliss, found guilty of murder in 1977. And it took until the twenty-first century for the rest—the FBI reopened the case in 1997, leading to the convictions of Thomas Blanton in 2001 and Bobby Frank Cherry in 2002, nearly forty years after the crime. A fourth suspect died before he could be charged. The significance of September 15, 1963 for the law is twofold. The bombing helped build the political will that produced the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965—the deaths of those four girls were not in vain in the sense that they hardened the nation’s resolve to write equality into law. And the decades-long road to conviction is a sobering lesson about accountability: that justice delayed is a profound injustice, but also that the law’s memory can be long, and that consequences can reach the responsible actors even many years after the fact. That last idea—that accountability shouldn’t expire just because time has passed or the guilty have moved on—runs, in a much quieter register, straight through my column today. In a significant loss for the administration, the Supreme Court has r...

Arizona Sues L'Oréal Over Hair-Relaxer Cancer Risks, a Second Judge Blocks the Mail-In Voting Rule, the "Loyalty Question" Falls & a ChatGPT Brief Backfires

9 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com This Day in Legal History: Theodore Roosevelt Sworn In On September 14, 1901, President William McKinley died in Buffalo, New York, eight days after being shot by an assassin at the Pan-American Exposition. That same afternoon, in the parlor of a private home, 42-year-old Vice President Theodore Roosevelt took the oath of office—administered by U.S. District Judge John R. Hazel—and became the youngest person ever to hold the presidency. The moment is a landmark in the constitutional law of presidential succession. The Constitution provided that the powers of the presidency “devolve” on the vice president upon the president’s death, but in 1901 the mechanics were still governed as much by precedent as by clear rule. Roosevelt’s swift, orderly assumption of office—taking the oath the very day McKinley died, before a federal judge, with the cabinet present—reinforced the norm of immediate, seamless succession that the country would rely on again and again. It wouldn’t be until the 25th Amendment, ratified in 1967, that the Constitution spelled out in detail how succession, vice-presidential vacancies, and presidential disability actually work. The significance of September 14, 1901 is twofold. It launched a presidency that would reshape American law—Roosevelt the trust-buster, whose antitrust campaign against the great monopolies gave real teeth to the Sherman Act, and Roosevelt the conservationist and regulator, who helped build the modern administrative state with agencies to police food, drugs, and railroads. And it stands as an early, sturdy example of the peaceful, lawful trans...

Texas Holds TikTok Liable Over Child Safety, 41% of Lawyers Say the Job Harmed Their Mental Health & California's New Kids-Online Laws

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com This Day in Legal History: September 11 and the Law Twenty-five years ago today, on September 11, 2001, coordinated terrorist attacks killed nearly 3,000 people and changed the United States in ways we are still reckoning with. Beyond the staggering human loss, September 11 set off one of the most profound transformations of American law in modern history—a rapid, sweeping reordering of the balance between security and liberty. The legal architecture came fast. Within a week, Congress passed the Authorization for Use of Military Force, a few dozen words that became the legal basis for two decades of military operations across the globe. In October, the USA PATRIOT Act dramatically expanded the government’s surveillance and investigative powers. The years that followed brought the military detention of “enemy combatants,” the prison at Guantanamo Bay, enhanced interrogation, expanded FISA surveillance, and a string of Supreme Court cases—Hamdi, Hamdan, Boumediene—in which the Court wrestled, haltingly, with whether and how the Constitution’s protections reach detainees in the war on terror. Those decisions reaffirmed a principle that had been under enormous pressure: that even in a national emergency, the executive is not beyond the reach of judicial review, and that habeas corpus and due process do not simply vanish because the government invokes security. The significance of September 11 for the law is that it forced the hardest version of a permanent question: how much liberty a free society should trade for safety, and who decides. Benjamin Franklin’s famous warning, in today’...

Court Tosses NESE Pipeline Permit, Chemours' $455M North Carolina PFAS Deal & Legal-AI's Harvey Hits $15.5 Billion

7 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com This Day in Legal History: Elias Howe and the Sewing Machine War On September 10, 1846, Elias Howe received U.S. Patent No. 4,750 for his lockstitch sewing machine—an invention that would revolutionize the manufacture of clothing and, less famously, trigger one of the most instructive intellectual-property battles in American legal history. Howe had the patent, but he struggled to commercialize it, and while he was away trying to raise money in England, others—most notably Isaac Singer—began building and selling sewing machines that incorporated his patented lockstitch. When Howe returned and demanded royalties, the result was years of litigation known as the “Sewing Machine War.” Multiple manufacturers held patents on different essential components; no one could build a complete, marketable machine without infringing someone else’s patent. It was the classic “patent thicket”—a tangle of overlapping rights that threatened to strangle the very innovation the patent system was supposed to encourage. The significance of September 10, 1846 is what the combatants did to escape that thicket. In 1856, the major players formed the Sewing Machine Combination—the first patent pool in American history. They agreed to cross-license their patents, put them into a common pool, and share royalties, with Howe collecting a fee on every machine sold in the United States. It let the industry actually function, and it made Howe enormously wealthy. But it also previewed a tension we still wrestle with in patent and antitrust law: patent pools can unlock innovation by clearing a thicket, or they can b...

SCOTUS Leaves Missouri's Map in Limbo, U.S. Resumes Visas for Hungary and Poland Only & Law Degrees Earned Behind Bars

7 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Attica Uprising On September 9, 1971, roughly 1,300 incarcerated men seized control of the Attica Correctional Facility in upstate New York, taking dozens of guards and staff hostage in what became the most significant prison uprising in American history. They were protesting brutal, degrading conditions—overcrowding, censorship, inadequate medical care, racial abuse—and their demands, issued in a list of grievances, were strikingly basic: adequate food, religious freedom, medical treatment, and to be treated, in the words of one of their leaders, like human beings and not beasts. The uprising ended four days later in horrific violence. On orders from state officials, troopers and guards retook the prison by force, firing indiscriminately into the yard. Thirty-nine people were killed in that assault—both incarcerated men and the hostages the state was supposedly trying to rescue—nearly all of them shot by the retaking forces. It was one of the bloodiest single days in American history between citizens and their own government, and the official cover story, that prisoners had killed the hostages, was quickly disproven by autopsies. The significance of September 9, 1971 is that Attica became a turning point for prisoners’ rights in American law. It galvanized a movement and a wave of litigation; it forced courts and legislatures to confront the conditions inside prisons and the constitutional rights that do not stop at the prison gate. The Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment, and later civil-rights suits under Section 1983, became...

Appeals Court Blocks SAVE Database for Voter Checks, the Montana License-Plate Loophole by the Numbers & Fixing NY's Charity Bottleneck

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: Ford Pardons Nixon On September 8, 1974, exactly one month after Richard Nixon resigned the presidency, his successor, Gerald Ford, granted him “a full, free, and absolute pardon” for all federal crimes he “committed or may have committed” while in office. In a single stroke, Ford ended the possibility that a former president would be criminally prosecuted for Watergate—and he did it before Nixon had even been charged with anything. The pardon was, and remains, one of the most controversial exercises of presidential power in American history. Ford defended it as an act of national healing, arguing that a prolonged prosecution of Nixon would keep the country trapped in the trauma of Watergate—that, as he put it, “our long national nightmare” needed to end. Critics were furious, many suspecting a corrupt bargain in which Ford had traded the pardon for the presidency. The decision almost certainly contributed to Ford’s narrow loss in the 1976 election. Ford himself later carried in his wallet a passage from the Supreme Court’s decision in Burdick v. United States, which held that accepting a pardon carries an imputation of guilt—his answer to those who said Nixon got off scot-free. The significance of September 8, 1974 is that it defined, in the most dramatic possible way, the breadth of the constitutional pardon power. The Constitution gives the president near-total authority to pardon federal offenses, and the Nixon pardon showed just how sweeping that is: it can be granted before charges are filed, for unspecified crimes, over enormous public objection...

Trump Takes Mail-In Voting Back to SCOTUS, IRS Targets Race-Conscious Schools' Tax Exemptions & Big Law Data Breaches

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Little Rock Nine On September 4, 1957, nine Black teenagers tried to walk into Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas—and were turned away at the doors by soldiers of the Arkansas National Guard, deployed by Governor Orval Faubus specifically to keep them out. The image of Elizabeth Eckford, one of the nine, walking alone through a jeering white mob, became one of the defining photographs of the civil rights era. And the confrontation it began became one of the most important tests of whether the rule of law actually means anything. The legal backdrop was Brown v. Board of Education, decided three years earlier, in which the Supreme Court held that segregated public schools are unconstitutional. Little Rock had a desegregation plan; the Little Rock Nine were supposed to be its first students. Governor Faubus decided to defy the federal courts, using state troops to block integration. The standoff escalated until President Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard and sent in the 101st Airborne Division to escort the nine students into the school—federal soldiers enforcing a federal court order against a state government determined to resist it. The significance of September 4, 1957 crystallized the following year in the Supreme Court’s decision in Cooper v. Aaron, which arose directly from the Little Rock crisis. There, in an opinion signed personally by all nine justices—a rare show of unanimity—the Court declared that state officials cannot nullify a federal court’s interpretation of the Constitution, and that “the federal judiciar...

Google Dodges an Ad-Tech Breakup, Boeing's $3.1M "Rounding Error" FAA Fine & the EPA's Blocked California Emissions Gambit

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Treaty of Paris On September 3, 1783, American and British negotiators signed the Treaty of Paris, formally ending the Revolutionary War and, with it, securing the thing the whole war had been fought over: British recognition of the independence of the United States. For the young nation, this was the moment it became, in the eyes of international law, a sovereign country among sovereign countries. The American delegation—Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, and John Jay—negotiated remarkably favorable terms. In its very first substantive article, Britain acknowledged the United States to be “free, sovereign and independent.” The treaty set generous boundaries, extending the new nation west to the Mississippi River, granted Americans valuable fishing rights off Newfoundland, and addressed the thorny questions of pre-war debts and the treatment of Loyalists. Franklin, ever the shrewd diplomat, had played the European powers against one another to extract terms far better than a defeated-looking rebellion might have expected. The significance of September 3, 1783 is foundational in the most literal sense. A declaration of independence is a claim; a treaty of peace in which your former ruler concedes that claim is its legal realization. The Treaty of Paris is the document in which the United States stopped being a rebellion and started being a nation with recognized borders, treaty-making power, and standing in the world. Everything that followed—the Constitution four years later, the entire edifice of American law—was built on the sovereignty this treaty s...

Charlie Kirk's Accused Killer Will Face a Death-Penalty Trial, Tiger Woods' 5-Year License Ban & Fixing Massachusetts Truck Taxes

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Brightlooks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Treasury Department Is Created On September 2, 1789, Congress passed the act establishing the Department of the Treasury—the third executive department created under the new Constitution, after Foreign Affairs and War, both of which we’ve marked on this show. A week or so later, President Washington would name Alexander Hamilton its first Secretary, and with that appointment, one of the most consequential careers in American governance began. The Treasury Department was, in a real sense, where the abstract new government became a functioning state. Hamilton inherited a country drowning in Revolutionary War debt, with no reliable revenue, no national bank, and shaky credit at home and abroad. Over the next few years, from that department, he engineered the financial architecture of the United States: the federal assumption of state debts, a system of customs duties and excise taxes to actually bring in revenue, the First Bank of the United States, and the establishment of public credit as a national asset. His conviction—captured in today’s opening quote—was that a manageable national debt, properly serviced, would knit the country’s creditors to its success and give the young republic financial standing in the world. The significance of September 2, 1789 is that the Treasury became, and remains, one of the most powerful institutions in American life. It runs the IRS, manages the public debt, enforces sanctions, and shapes economic policy in ways that touch every person in the country. The debates Hamilton started—about debt, about taxation, about ho...

"Keffe D" Guilty in Tupac Murder, Trump Fights On for Mail-In Voting Curbs & SCOTUS Lets the White House Ballroom Rise

7 min

This Day in Legal History: Aaron Burr Acquitted of Treason On September 1, 1807, a jury in Richmond, Virginia acquitted Aaron Burr—the former Vice President of the United States—of treason, in what remains the only time such a high-ranking American official has ever been tried for that crime. The verdict was delivered in memorably grudging terms: the jury said Burr was “not proved to be guilty under this indictment by any evidence submitted to us.” Burr had allegedly conspired to carve an independent republic out of western territory, but he walked free. The reason he walked free is one of the most important principles in American criminal law. The framers of the Constitution, remembering how English kings had used vague, elastic treason charges to destroy their political enemies, deliberately wrote the narrowest possible definition into Article III: treason against the United States consists only of levying war against them, or adhering to their enemies, and—crucially—no one can be convicted except on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on confession in open court. Presiding over the trial was Chief Justice John Marshall, and Marshall enforced that definition strictly. He held that mere conspiracy, mere intention, mere assemblage of men was not enough—the government had to prove an actual overt act of levying war, with two witnesses. It couldn’t, and Burr was acquitted. The significance of September 1, 1807 is layered. It was a dramatic clash between the branches: President Thomas Jefferson desperately wanted Burr convicted and worked behind the scenes to make it happen, while Marshall’s court insisted on rigorous proof and refused to bend to political pressure—even subpoenaing the president himself for documents. It cemented the idea that “treason” cannot be a catch-all for disloyalty, and that an independent judiciary must hold the line on proof even when a president demands a scalp. On a day featuring both a murder verdict and several tests...

Judge Rules Pro-Palestinian Deportations Unconstitutional, Big Law Leasing Surges 17% & CXMT Sues the Pentagon

7 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Brightlooks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Neutrality Act of 1935 On August 31, 1935, President Franklin Roosevelt signed the first of what would become a series of Neutrality Acts—laws designed to keep the United States out of the wars gathering in Europe and Asia. This first act imposed a mandatory embargo on shipping arms and ammunition to any nation the president declared to be at war, and it put America’s armaments industry under a measure of federal control. It was a legal expression of the deep isolationism that gripped the country between the world wars. Here’s the constitutional wrinkle that makes it interesting, and that Roosevelt himself chafed against. FDR wanted flexibility—he asked Congress for a law that would let him embargo arms to an aggressor nation while still selling weapons to its victim. Congress refused. Instead, it wrote a rigid, evenhanded rule: once the president declared that a state of war existed, he had to embargo arms to all sides, aggressor and victim alike. That was a deliberate congressional choice to tie the executive’s hands in foreign affairs, to prevent a president from drawing the country toward one belligerent or another. Roosevelt signed it reluctantly, believing he could get it revised—and over the next several years, as the threat from fascism grew undeniable, the Neutrality Acts were indeed loosened, culminating in Lend-Lease and, ultimately, American entry into the war. The significance of August 31, 1935 is as a case study in the perennial struggle between Congress and the president over foreign affairs, and in the moral limits of legal neutrali...

Meta's $18B Child-Harm Settlement, Tate Brothers' Extradition Bail Fight & Bayer's $7.25B Roundup Deal Advances

8 min

This Day in Legal History: The Murder of Emmett Till On August 28, 1955, fourteen-year-old Emmett Till was abducted, tortured, and murdered in the Mississippi Delta by two white men, Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam, after Till—a Black teenager visiting from Chicago—was accused of offending a white woman in a grocery store. His killers beat him, shot him, weighted his body, and threw it in the Tallahatchie River. He was a child, and his murder, and what came after, helped ignite the modern civil rights movement. The legal story is one of justice utterly failing, and then, slowly, refusing to disappear. Bryant and Milam were tried the next month in a segregated Mississippi courtroom. The trial lasted five days; the all-white, all-male jury deliberated for barely an hour before acquitting both men, with one juror later saying it wouldn’t have taken that long if they hadn’t stopped for a soda. Protected by double jeopardy, the two men then sold their confession to a magazine for a few thousand dollars, describing in detail how they’d killed the boy they had just been acquitted of murdering. It was one of the starkest demonstrations imaginable that the machinery of Southern justice was not built to deliver justice to Black victims. The significance of August 28, 1955 reaches across the decades. Emmett’s mother, Mamie Till-Mobley, made the searing decision to hold an open-casket funeral and let the world photograph her son. That act of witness galvanized a generation. And there is a haunting piece of calendar symmetry worth honoring: exactly eight years later, on August 28, 1963, Martin Luther King Jr. stood at the Lincoln Memorial and delivered the “I Have a Dream” speech to the March on Washington. The law eventually, partially, caught up—the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, and, only in 2022, a federal anti-lynching law that bears Emmett Till’s name. It’s a reminder that some of the most important developments in American law began not in a courtroom win, but in a co...

Judge Weighs Kennedy Center Trump Signage, Lisa Cook Fights Fed Removal & X Loses NY Hate-Speech Suit

7 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Bright looks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Kellogg-Briand Pact On August 27, 1928, representatives of fifteen nations gathered in Paris and signed the Kellogg-Briand Pact—an international agreement in which the signatories solemnly renounced war as an instrument of national policy. Named for U.S. Secretary of State Frank Kellogg and French Foreign Minister Aristide Briand, it was born of the still-fresh horror of World War I and the earnest hope that the great powers could simply agree to stop settling disputes by force. Eventually 64 nations signed on. It is, on its face, one of the most idealistic documents in the history of international law—and one of the most famous cautionary tales about law’s limits. The pact had a fatal flaw: it contained no enforcement mechanism, no sanctions, no army, nothing but the promise itself and the hope that world opinion would keep nations honest. Within a few years, that hope was in tatters—Japan invaded Manchuria, Italy invaded Ethiopia, Germany rearmed, and the whole edifice collapsed into the Second World War. As a device for preventing war, Kellogg-Briand failed almost completely. And yet the significance of August 27, 1928 is more complicated than “noble failure.” The pact planted a legal idea that outlived its own impotence: that aggressive war is not just tragic but unlawful. After World War II, that principle became the backbone of the Nuremberg trials, where Nazi leaders were prosecuted for “crimes against peace”—waging aggressive war—a charge that traced its lineage directly to Kellogg-Briand. So the pact is a genuinely instructive anniversary...

Kennedy Center Renaming Defies a Court Order?, Deloitte's $21.5M DEI Settlement & Ninth Circuit Blocks Ideological Grant Strings

8 min

We’ve launched Minimum Competence CLE, and our first course is now available completely free. Researching Federal Tax Issues After Loper Brightlooks at how the Supreme Court’s decision ending Chevron deference changes the way lawyers should research and evaluate Treasury regulations, IRS guidance, and other federal tax authorities. Take the course and earn CLE credit at cle.minimumcomp.com. This Day in Legal History: The Declaration of the Rights of Man On August 26, 1789, France’s National Assembly adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, one of the foundational documents of modern constitutional government. The Marquis de Lafayette played a major role in drafting it, with input from his friend Thomas Jefferson, who was then serving as the American minister in Paris. In just seventeen articles, the Declaration tried to turn Enlightenment ideas about natural rights and legitimate government into law. A lot of it will sound familiar to American ears, in part because the American and French revolutions were very much in conversation with each other. Article I declares that “men are born and remain free and equal in rights”—today’s opening quote. The Declaration identifies liberty, property, security, and resistance to oppression as natural rights. It says the law must apply equally, punishment must be authorized by law, defendants are presumed innocent, and the free communication of ideas is “one of the most precious of the rights of man.” It also makes separation of powers part of the definition of constitutional government: a society where rights are not secured and powers are not separated “has no constitution at all.” The Declaration mattered well beyond France. Its ideas influenced constitutions throughout Europe and Latin America and eventually found echoes in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. There was also an enormous gap between the Declaration’s promises and what followed. Within a few years, the French Revolution had...

Up next

  1. Nothing queued. Use + Queue on any episode to line it up.

0:00 0:00