Don Fanelli

Mutterfly

A Improv , Comedy and Comedy Interviews podcast Explicit

About the show

Three Improv Duos. Two Lines. Endless Possibilities. What happens when three pairs of improvisers are given the exact same opening lines, but have no idea what they, or their partners, are about to say? In every episode of Mutterfly, host Don Fanelli throws three improv duos immediately into the deep end. Starting with the same two scripted lines, each pair must improvise their way to a conclusion. The result? Three "Mutters" with wildly different, hilarious, and unpredictable outcomes. It’s a high-wire improv comedy experiment where the only thing guaranteed is that no two scenes will ever be the same. Follow the Mutters on Instagram: @mutterflythepod

Newest episodes

I've Got Three Buttcheeks

Aug 13, 2026 28 min

SEASON 1 FINALE! In our Season 1 Finale, we explore a porno scenario that does not meet expectations, a friend-to-friend confession, and a disturbing family funeral. Mutter 1: Jeff Hiller + Lauren Lapkus Mutter 2: Craig Cackowski + Ben Rodgers Mutter 3: Paul Scheer + Rob Huebel Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Yo, How Many Pushups Can You Do?

Aug 6, 2026 29 min

In this episode, we explore the complicated relationships of two best friends, two lovers, and three weird-ass neighbors. Mutter 1: Benjamin Apple + James Dwyer Mutter 2: Johnny McNulty + Katie Marovitch Mutter 3: Billy Merritt + Shannon O'Neill Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I'm 355 Years Old, Today

Jul 30, 2026 29 min

In this episode, we explore the absolute worst "friend," a prankster grandma, and an old zombie mummy who can't eat or drink. Mutter 1: Tao Yang + Jake Cornell Mutter 2: Greg Tuculescu + Hillary Anne Matthews Mutter 3: Sarah Claspell + Beth Appel Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Similar podcasts

The Basement Yard Santagato Studios

Son of a Boy Dad Barstool Sports

ok storytime iHeartPodcasts

The Broski Report with Brittany Broski Brittany Broski & Audioboom Studios

CumTown Vincent van Sploog

Not Another D&D Podcast Headgum

Dungeons and Daddies Dungeons and Daddies

Shootin' the Sh!t with Tracy & Martina Tracy and Martina

All episodes

I've Got Three Buttcheeks

Aug 13, 2026 28 min

Yo, How Many Pushups Can You Do?

Aug 6, 2026 29 min

I'm 355 Years Old, Today

Jul 30, 2026 29 min

I Usually Just Eat Them

Jul 23, 2026 32 min

In this episode, we explore the aftermath of an overly aggressive pitch meeting, an awkward fraternity rush, and three guys with strange habits waiting at a bus stop. Mutter 1: Ben Rodgers + Craig Cackowski Mutter 2: Marshall Stratton + James Coker Mutter 3: Benjamin Apple + James Dwyer Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I Don't Eat Vegetables

Jul 16, 2026 27 min

In this episode, we encounter some mixed and confusing innuendo, three men named Cliff, and a mother with a pet octopus. Mutter 1: Jerah Milligan + Lily Du Mutter 2: Katie Marovitch + Johnny McNulty Mutter 3: Laura Willcox + Lauren Adams Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

$450,000

Jul 9, 2026 34 min

In this episode, we explore a delusional couple trying to sell a no-bathroom house with four kitchens, the idea of a hearing-ear dog, and degenerate gambling spouses willing to let their daughter tank her performance. Mutter 1: Glenn Boozan + Andrew Ford Mutter 2: Justin Tyler + Alden Ford Mutter 3: Craig Rowin + Cathryn Mudon Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

We're in the Parking Lot of a Chuck E. Cheese

Jun 18, 2026 34 min

In this episode, we meet the most positive bride-to-be in the world, a manager trying on dresses during her smoke break, and a chemist who splices clothes together to ill-fated results. Mutter 1: Patrick Noth + Morgan Evans Mutter 2: Monique Moses + Alex Fernie Mutter 3: Beth Appel + Sarah Claspell Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Barack Hussein BoBama

Jun 11, 2026 27 min

In this episode, we explore a relationship on the rocks, mistaken fetishes, a failed attempt at a catchphrase, and a very trustworthy co-worker. Mutter 1: Lauren Lapkus + Jeff Hiller Mutter 2: Mike Antonucci + Daniel Spenser Mutter 3: Achilles Stamatelaky + Carl Tart Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Ketchup and Mustard Make Toothpaste

Jun 4, 2026 33 min

In this episode, we explore an awkward breakup involving a roommate and a volleyball team, the financial and familial fallout of becoming a professional lifeguard, and a candid date in a very long hallway. Mutter 1: Jake Cornell + Tao Yang Mutter 2: James Coker + Marshall Stratton Mutter 3: Jen Bartels + George Kareman This episodes First Two Lines were submitted by Becca Boerman! Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Pee-wee Herman Was My Father

May 28, 2026 27 min

In this episode, we explore a secret that delays eight dudes from going camping in a VW Van, two offended hikers, and celebrities based on the fathers of two friends. Featuring... kind of, sort of Captain Hippo: Daniel Spenser + Mike Antonucci Andrew Ford + Glenn Boozan Michael Hartney + Connor Ratliff Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

They Call Me The Space Cowboy

May 21, 2026 30 min

In this episode, we follow an old lady delivering messages from the mothers of two career-wayward men, two astronauts discovering different ways to kiss, and a garage door repairman who lives vicariously through his brother. Mutter 1: Lily Du + Jerah Milligan Mutter 2: Shannon O'Neill + Billy Merritt Mutter 3: Rob Huebel + Paul Scheer Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Actually, the 'G' is Silent

May 14, 2026 34 min

In this episode, we explore the rekindling of a high school relationship, the attempt to change an actress's personality in five minutes, and the creepy interpretations of a painting. Mutter 1: George Kareman + Jen Bartels Mutter 2: Monique Moses + Alex Fernie Mutter 3: Hillary Anne Matthews + Greg Tuculescu Thank you to listener Jarred Roberts for providing this episode's First Two Lines. Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I've Been to Twelve DIfferent Summer Camps

May 7, 2026 33 min

In this episode, we meet a delusional public defender, explore the struggles among a busy father, an erudite daughter, and a barista-turned-camp director, and watch a helpless prisoner plead with a lost camper. Mutter 1: Carl Tart + Achilles Stamatelaky Mutter 2: Cathryn Mudon + Craig Rowin Mutter 3: Connor Ratliff + Michael Hartney Thank you to listener Anthony Lucchi for providing this episode's First Two Lines. Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I'm a Fuggin Mannequin

Apr 30, 2026 32 min

In this episode, we explore how a cursed apple led to a life at Best Buy, the necessity of having g******s while eating, and the wildly different aspirations of Macy's workers. Mutter 1: Morgan Evans + Patrick Noth Mutter 2: Natasha Vaynblat + Rekha Shankar Mutter 3: Jon Braylock + Jeremy Bent Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Don't Move, They're Watching Us

Apr 23, 2026 26 min

In this episode, we encounter an ex-army ranger with confusing instructions, a hot-wired house in a child-terrorized neighborhood, and poor party planning. Mutter 1: Tim Martin + Josh Patten Mutter 2: Glo Tavares + Moujan Zolfaghari Mutter 3: Jon Gabrus + Dan Klein Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I'm Starting a War

Apr 16, 2026 26 min

In this episode, we explore a furious children's book illustrator, the decline of academia, and moving on from the circus. Mutter 1: Betsy Sodaro + Richie Moriarty Mutter 2: Brandon Gardner + Neil Casey Mutter 3: Sebastian Conelli + Michael Cruz Kane Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com DM on Instagram: @mutterflythepod Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

What About the Lollypops?

Apr 9, 2026 34 min

In this episode, we explore the importance of love in a scissors company, a conga-line-loving boss, and keeping your personal life separate from your work life. Mutter 1: Dan Lippert + Ryan Rosenberg Mutter 2: Kate Zelensky + Terry Withers Mutter 3: Casey Feigh + Marcy Jarreau Submit your own First Two Lines, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! DM on Insta: @mutterflythepod Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I'm Just a Fat Old Ghost

Apr 2, 2026 22 min

In this episode, we explore a rigid ghost prone to scary outbursts, an unconventional father-daughter relationship, and a clumsy divorcee on the prowl for slippery men. Mutter 1: D'Arcy Carden + Abbi Jacobson Mutter 2: Mary Holland + Sean Diston Mutter 3: Josh Sharp + Aaron Jackson Want to submit your own First Two Lines to be used in a future episode? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com Insta DM: @mutterflythepod Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Ugh, I Have Honey in My Hair

Mar 26, 2026 21 min

In this episode, we explore an emotional army captain facing a looming threat, an unhelpful robotic spaceship assistant, and male baldness during battle. Mutter 1: Grant O'Brien + Brennan Lee Mulligan Mutter 2: Jim Santangeli + Alex Dickson Mutter 3: Mike Castle + Marques Ray Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Mission to Zyxx: My Fingers Look Like Jizzy Snakes

Mar 19, 2026 34 min

In this episode, we celebrate with cast members of Mission to Zyxx and explore the colonization of a planet gone wrong, witch sisters and their misogynistic prisoner, and the devastating secrets revealed on a commune. Mutter 1: Alden Ford and Justin Tyler Mutter 2: Moujan Zolfaghari and Glo Tavares Mutter 3: Jeremy Bent and Jon Braylock Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I've Been Struck By Lightning Five Times

Mar 12, 2026 37 min

In this episode, we explore eating food through one's a*****e, clashing with a toilet paper company's values, and the confusing ways employees rate themselves. Mutter 1: Dan Klein and Jon Gabrus Mutter 2: Rekha Shankar and Natasha Vaynblat Mutter 3: Aaron Jackson and Dru Johnston Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I Ate a Hammer

Mar 5, 2026 28 min

In this episode, we explore the obvious consequences of a drunken adventure, a vindictive and inappropriate doctor, and a therapy-proud couple with wildly complicated role-play backstories. Mutter 1: Brian McElhaney and Nick Kocher Mutter 2: Joey Greer and Caroline Cotter Mutter 3: Chris Gethard and Will Hines Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

I Can Put My Leg Over My Head

Feb 26, 2026 25 min

In this episode, we explore pre-birth crab hands, contortionist classes for jobless men, and unique boy names like Spider, Table, and Lumber. Mutter 1: Shaun Diston and Mary Holland Mutter 2: Laura Willcox and Dan Black Mutter 3: Marcy Jarreau and Casey Feigh Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

F**k Th*t Shit: "I'm Covered in Bird Ass"

Feb 19, 2026 31 min

A special episode with F**k Th*t Shit (A Comedy Team) In this episode, we explore bird sex, the insufferableness of speech and debate, and brother rivalries. Mutter 1: Terry Withers and Kate Zelenski Mutter 2: Dru Johnston and Aaron Jackson Mutter 3: Josh Patten and Tim Martin Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

What Happened to Your Face?

Feb 12, 2026 35 min

In this episode, we explore the unfortunate realities of a Halloween gone wrong, including a shocking presidential reveal, a cringeworthy romantic misadventure, and the disastrous results of dog breeding. Our Mutters: Mutter 1: Phil Augusta Jackson and Nicole Byer Mutter 2: Neil Casey and Brandon Gardner Mutter 3: Mike Castle and Marques Ray Want to submit your own First Two Lines? DM mutterflythepod on Instagram or Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Daylight Come and We Wanna Go Home

Feb 5, 2026 35 min

In this episode, we explore Mickey Mouse's uncut dingdong, way too specific anniversary gifts, and a love of Beetlejuice. Our Mutters: Mutter 1: Aaron Jackson and Josh Sharp Mutter 2: Dan Lippert and Ryan Rosenberg Mutter 3: Dan Black and Laura Wilcox Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTLs, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

That's A Lot of Peanut Butter & Jelly

Jan 29, 2026 30 min

In this episode, we explore the parallel lives of mechanics, getting knocked up by a vending machine guy, and the history of Peeps and its relation to penises. Mutter 1: Michael Cruz Kane and Sebastian CanelliMutter 2: Caroline Cotter and Joey Greer Mutter 3: Alex Dickson and Jim Santangeli Want to submit your own First Two Lines? Email: mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text: 657-222-1324. Leave a message with your FTL, and you might hear it on a future Mutterfly! Like, subscribe, and leave a review to help make more Mutters!

Sorry, My Eyes Are Bleeding

Jan 22, 2026 27 min

"Sorry, My Eyes Are Bleeding" In this episode, we explore hoaxes, walking babies, and a podcast studio once used by Pennywise the Clown. Mutter 1: Brennan Lee Mulligan and Grant O'BrienMutter 2: Richie Moriarty and Betsy SodaroMutter 3: Nick Kocher and Brian McElhaneyLike, rate, and subscribe! Want to submit your own First Two Lines to be used on a future episode? Email mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text 657-222-1324.

Because of the Deaths?

Jan 21, 2026 32 min

In our first episode, we dive into the wild worlds of workplace mishaps, animal casualties, and the longing for fatherhood. Mutter 1: Chris Gethard and Will Hines Mutter 2: Nicole Byer and Phil Augusta Jackson Mutter 3: Abbi Jacobson and D'Arcy Carden Want to submit your own First Two Lines to be used on a future episode? Email mutterflythepod@gmail.com or Call/Text 657-222-1324.

–

0 ratings from members

Rate this podcast

No reviews yet — be the first member to rate "Mutterfly".

This podcast, its content and its artwork are not owned by, affiliated with, or endorsed by Castquire.

I've Got Three Buttcheeks

Share this podcast

Live Chart rankings

#91 Improv 🇨🇦 CA

Chart history

🇨🇦 Improv Best #72

Podcast details

Created by: Don Fanelli
Status: Inactive
Latest episode: Aug 13, 2026
Episodes: 29
Release period: Weekly
Avg. episode length: 30 min
Explicit: Yes
Language: English

Links

Official website ↗ Apple Podcasts ↗ RSS feed ↗

Is this your podcast?

Claim it to show it on your profile. Using the email from your RSS feed approves it instantly.

Keep listening

Discover more podcasts like this.

Browse podcasts See the charts